Not all strong criticisms of Expelled have been vitriolic or ad hominem. See Jeffrey Klugers "Ben Stein Dukes it Out
with Darwin" in Time, 4/10/08. While nailing the movie, it closes with
analogous criticisms of Dawkins and company. [Nevertheless, DI responded as if
it were a one-sided attack piece.] For
very emphatic but largely ad hominem free repudiation, see the triad of reviews
by Shermer, Rennie, and Minrsky in Scientific
American, April 2008.
To return to the previous topic,
click on your browser's 'Back' button.