View by:  Subject  Theme  Question  Term  Person  Event

Body-of-God Theories of Divine Action

The best way to compare theories of divine action in detail is to ask - what, for each theory, is ‘the causal joint’ at which God - as a transcendent, immaterial world cause - interacts particularly with causative factors in the material world?

The use of the image of the world-as-the-body-of-GodSee God, Humanity and the Cosmos, pp214-16is the one which makes strongest use of the analogy of human action, as mental beings on physical bodies. But immediately it runs into problems. One is that we still understand so little about how human agency works. What we do know is that in the case of human action, descriptions in terms of the mental, the intentional, are grounded in the physical. The human ‘intender’ is not an autonomous entity existing independently of nerves and muscles; it is a body containing a brain. And as soon as we ground God in the physical world by making that world God’s body we run into problems. John Polkinghorne points out that pressing this analogy either places God too much in thrall to the world (unable to act autonomously because God is dependent on the inputs from God’s body, as human action is) or the world too much in thrall to God (humans could no more act freely than an organ of the body can).Polkinghorne, J, Science and Providence, (London: SPCK, 1989) pp18-21 - see also God, Humanity and the Cosmos, p215-16. The difficulty is illustrated by the fact that Sallie McFague, one of the most eloquent... So this model cannot locate the causal joint except by risking other very substantial theological problems.

Email link | Feedback | Contributed by: Dr. Christopher Southgate
Source: God, Humanity and the Cosmos  (T&T Clark, 1999)

A Test Case - Divine Action

Index - God, Humanity and the Cosmos, 1999 T&T Clark

Body-of-God Theories of Divine Action

Related Book Topics:

An Introduction to Divine Action: Isaac Newton’s God
God of the Gaps
Determinism, Indeterminism and Their Implications
Law, Chance and Divine Action
Different Understandings of Chance
How to Think About Providential Agency
A Classification of Theories of Divine Action
Neo-Thomist Views of Divine Action
Peacocke’s View of Divine Action
Polkinghorne’s View of Divine Action
Quantum-Based Proposals on Divine Action
Criticisms of Quantum-Based Proposals on Divine Action
Process Models of Divine Action
Peacocke and Polkinghorne Compared
Peacocke and Polkinghorne: Comparison of Models of Divine Action
The Question of Miracle
The Resurrection of Jesus
The Virginal Conception of Jesus
Science and Divine Action


Dr. Christopher Southgate in God, Humanity and the Cosmos. Published by T&T Clark.

See also:

Isaac Newton
Charles Darwin
Does God Act?
Ward on Divine Action